This review is directly connected to our field.
In this video, Alan Walker introduces himself and his co-producer and attempts to explain how his latest track was made. However, throughout the entire tutorial, there is a strong impression that he has barely interacted with the project and doesn’t fully understand what he’s describing.
He appears visibly uncomfortable, frequently looking to his assistant for guidance. At one point, he is unable to explain a basic sawtooth wave, even though its image is displayed on the screen, and has to click on the oscillator to figure it out. At the same time, he openly shows the face of his assistant, which only amplifies the confusion.
This reaction stands in contrast to how established DJs who actively produce their own music usually behave. They tend to speak confidently about sound design, sample sources, and their personal production techniques. Even when a co-producer is involved, that person rarely appears on camera.
As a result, many viewers concluded that the track was a ghost production. Fans felt disappointed to realize their idol might not be the creative genius they imagined, while critics felt validated in calling him overrated. Underneath these reactions lies a common belief: a DJ should play a meaningful role in producing their own music.
